One Heartbreaking Moment Reveals a Brutal Truth About Amy’s Past

Editor’s Note: The following contains spoilers for Doc Season 2 Episode 2.The Season 2 premiere of Doc, “Her Heart,” threw us right back into the chaos with a harrowing hospital hostage crisis that left TJ (Patrick Walker) wounded, triggered Amy’s (Molly Parker) first real flashes of memory, and pushed Michael (Omar Metwally) to the brink as his wife gave birth in the middle of it all. It was an emotional, high-stakes return that also spotlighted a glaring issue at Westside: with Amy still recovering from her accident and Richard Miller’s (Scott Wolf) departure in the Season 1 finale, the chief of internal medicine position remained vacant.

Episode 2, “Delusions of Grandeur,” finally addressed that void with the introduction of a new character poised to shake things up for Amy and the entire hospital. While it didn’t match the nonstop chaos of the premiere, the episode offered a compelling medical case, meaningful character moments and the promise of even bigger conflicts ahead.

Felicity Huffman Debuts as Dr. Joan Ridley in Episode 2 of ‘Doc’

Back in June, after Doc secured a rare 22-episode order, it was announced that Felicity Huffman would be joining the cast as Dr. Joan Ridley, Amy’s former mentor. Episode 2 marks her official debut, and from the moment she strides into Westside with a trio of nervous interns trailing behind her, the tone shifts. As one of them says, Amy was once Joan’s best pupil, and seeing her again stirs something deeper. Amy begins to experience more fragmented flashes of memory: A slice of cake, a glass of whiskey, a crowded restaurant. They’re more like puzzle pieces than answers, but it’s clear that Joan is a trigger, and those memories are leading somewhere significant.

Joan wastes no time making her presence felt. In a quiet but telling conversation with Michael, she offers him advice about the still-vacant chief of internal medicine role. With the hospital pressuring him to take paternity leave after the chaos of the premiere, Joan counsels him not to hand the position to anyone who actually “wants it”. On the surface, it plays like a mentor giving hard-earned wisdom, but it’s hard not to believe that she’s planting the seed for herself.

Her brilliance is also on full display when she treats a patient suffering from an 11-day bout of hiccups (which sounds like pure torture), impressing everyone around her with her expert ability to diagnose. Huffman plays Joan with a sharp blend of toughness and empathy, the kind of doctor who commands respect without having to ask for it. Still, beneath that polished exterior, there’s an unmistakable edge of mystery. It becomes clear by the end of the episode that Joan may have an agenda of her own in returning to Westside.

Amy and Gina Work Together on The Main Medical Case of the Week In Episode 2

The main medical case in Episode 2 follows Megan, a young woman suffering with severe abdominal pain and claiming that she’s pregnant. It’s evident that she’s never actually seen a doctor before though, seemingly living in a cult-like group off the grid. However, Amy and Gina (Amirah Vann) uncover the heartbreaking truth that Megan was never pregnant and instead has a massive tumor that her delusion makes worse. It was one of the show’s most compelling cases yet, and in typical Doc fashion, it raised just as many questions for the doctors as it did answers for the patient.

Treating Megan proves tricky for Amy and Gina, who initially lie to her so she still believes she’s pregnant, hoping to protect her from a psychotic break. But when the truth finally comes out, Megan lashes out, even punching Amy, before she’s able to start facing reality. The case ends with both medical care and an emotional reunion with her long-lost brother, but more importantly, it pushes Amy and Gina to confront their past.

Amy finally asks Gina what really happened between them during the eight years she can’t remember. Gina admits that when Amy lost her son Danny, she lost her too, describing it as “a thousand cuts” that slowly damaged their friendship. It’s a heartbreaking but necessary moment, especially when Amy asks how to fix it and Gina replies, “a thousand stitches.” Parker and Vann are fantastic in the scene and, with Vann getting more screen time this season, it feels like we’re about to learn a lot more about their dynamic.

TJ’s Recovery and Sonya’s Frustration Set Up Big Conflict in ‘Doc’ Season 2

Meanwhile, TJ is quickly proving to be the worst patient imaginable. Still reeling from being shot in the premiere, he learns recovery will take far longer than he hoped. According to the doctor, it’ll be six months before walking normally and up to a year before running or playing sports. Frustrated, he ignores medical advice, tries to get up on his own, and immediately falls. His short temper flares at the nurses, until Amy steps in to talk him down. Their scenes resonate because Amy spent much of last season being a terrible patient herself, and TJ’s respect for her makes the advice hit harder. Watching him struggle with vulnerability while Amy mirrors her own recovery feels like it’ll be an ongoing throughline this year.

But the real spark comes when Sonya (Anya Banerjee) pulls Amy in to handle TJ and instead turns her frustration on Amy. Sonya accuses her of being the reason TJ nearly got killed, pointing to Amy’s missing memories as a liability. I understand her point, but it feels unfair in the moment and exposes the deeper cracks in their dynamic. With Amy and Jake (Jon Ecker) already on shaky ground, and Sonya’s obvious feelings for Jake bubbling under the surface, this conflict is poised to get even messier as the season unfolds.

The Final Moments of Doc Season 2, Episode 2 Set the Stage for What’s Ahead

By the end of the episode, Michael officially offers Joan the chief position, and while she negotiates the terms, it’s clear she knows exactly how to play her cards. When Gina later finds Joan sitting in Michael’s chair, it feels like the shift is already happening, and it’s immediately clear that Gina is not a fan of Joan, especially sitting in the chair that truly belongs to Amy. After Gina tells Amy that Joan will be the new chief, her full memory comes together.

We see Joan telling Amy she has “no choice” but to leave Michael. It’s a brutal revelation, one that re-frames Amy’s grief after losing her son. Amy saw Michael as the man who failed their child, and Joan sees that as holding Amy back from being the brilliant doctor she could be. While it’s unclear if what Amy saw is completely reliable given her unconventional methods to recover her memories, it still raises a huge question: how will Amy process this moving forward? Episode 2 might not have had the chaos of the premiere, but its final moments proved Doc is setting up a season full of messy emotions, shifting power dynamics and plenty more secrets and memories to be uncovered.

All new episodes of Doc air Tuesdays on FOX and next day on Hulu.